Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Appellate Court says EID must seek removal of rancheria water restrictions

From page A4 | October 12, 2012 | 4 Comments

On Oct. 4, the California Third Appellate Court ruled that the El Dorado Irrigation District, which supplies water to the Shingle Springs Band of Miwok Indians, must seek permission from the Local Agency Formation Commission to continue to do so, and if such permission is not granted, EID and the sovereign tribe must take the matter to court for judicial relief.

However, by existing court order, so long as EID is working with LAFCO to remove certain water restrictions — as it is doing — then EID can continue to provide water service to the tribe.

The matter involves water restrictions LAFCO imposed when approving the annexation of the tribe’s trust lands into EID’s service area in 1988. LAFCO restricted the amount of water the tribe could receive to only that needed for 40 residential lots, limited governmental purposes, and no commercial purposes.

The restrictions are unprecedented in that LAFCO has never before or after imposed such restrictions on an applicant for water service from EID, the tribe noted. For its part, EID has a “first come, first serve” policy for its customers.

The U.S. Department of Interior, tribe and EID all have concluded what the tribe calls LAFCO’s “patently discriminatory restrictions — targeting only the Tribe” — are illegal and unenforceable as a matter of federal law.

State or local agencies cannot, without violating federal law, purport to control the land use of sovereign territory, tribal officials stated. And the original effect and intent of the water restrictions was to control the tribe’s use of its own land and ability to pursue economic development (since water is essential).

The legality of the restrictions was not an issue that was before the California Court of Appeal for decision. Without reaching that issue, the Court of Appeal ruled that EID could not just disregard the restrictions under California law, at least not without first formally applying to LAFCO to remove them.

“We were hoping the state appellate court would see the injustice of all of this, and undo it. It chose a different course,” said Nicholas Fonseca, chairman of the Shingle Springs Band of Miwok Indians. “What the judges did not know is that we tried to work with LAFCO, and ask them to remove the restrictions. That body was not interested at the time because certain people then sitting on the LAFCO were politically opposed to our effort to build a casino. Now that Red Hawk Casino is a reality, that view may have changed.”

Notwithstanding the tribe’s appeal to the Court of Appeal, the U.S. Department of Interior and EID have been working to remove the restrictions through a formal application to LAFCO. That application remains pending, and should be presented for formal action in December. It follows an effort by EID, the United States and the tribe to resolve the matter informally, through entry of a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the parties.

In June 2008, after the Department of Interior’s Regional Solicitor had issued an opinion concluding the water restrictions were illegal and unenforceable, the tribe and EID entered an MOU that would allow EID to provide water to the tribe, consistent with the “first come, first serve” policy that applies to all others. In exchange, the tribe agreed to pay the commercial rate for water (even though it is a government, entitled to a governmental rate).

The tribe also agreed to upgrade water-delivery infrastructure on the reservation, an upgrade that positively affected water pressure not only on the reservation, but within the surrounding community.

A local group opposing the tribe’s casino — Voices for Rural Living or VRL—  then challenged the MOU on the ground that it violated state environmental law, in that an environmental impact report had to be prepared before more water could be provided the tribe.

The Court of Appeal disagreed with this argument, ruling that no EIR was actually required in order to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act. However, VRL also argued EID and the tribe could not, under California law, disregard the water restrictions, without LAFCO’s involvement. The Court of Appeal agreed with this argument.

For its part, while the tribe appealed the ruling to the Court of Appeal, EID agreed to prepare another EIR to evaluate the water impacts and support its application to LAFCO to remove the restrictions.

The EIR and application to LAFCO have been issued for public comment, and a hearing will likely occur this fall. In the meantime, the El Dorado County Superior Court already has ruled that EID can continue to provide the tribe water so long as EID works to secure removal of the restrictions.

Prior to this EIR, the tribe and two federal agencies had already prepared an environmental analysis evaluating the impacts of delivering water to the tribe’s gaming facility. That environmental document found that while the tribe could truck water into Red Hawk Casino on a daily basis, the environmental impacts associated with delivering water to the Rancheria by pipe were far less impactful.

“We hope LAFCO does the right thing, and removes the restrictions once and for all,” said Fonseca. “If it does not, we are confident a federal court will right this wrong, since the restrictions so clearly violate federal law, which is an issue the state court did not reach.”


Discussion | 4 comments

  • Phillip VeerkampOctober 07, 2012 - 5:44 pm

    LAFCO is racist?

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Miwok NationOctober 13, 2012 - 1:06 pm

    Emily, you forgot to mention the 1988 application was made by Sacramento Verona band. Would you like to see the LAFCO document? Please post a correction. Thanks Miwok Nation

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Miwok NationOctober 13, 2012 - 1:09 pm

    Here is the appplicant, please publish a correction

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • Justin acuñaOctober 13, 2012 - 4:24 pm

    If there tribe was ran by and was entirely native American they should have has much water as they need. But there tribe will not prove there native American.

    Reply | Report abusive comment


EDH Fire Dept. annexing Latrobe

By Noel Stack | From Page: A1

Motorcycle fatality in Greenwood

By Cole Mayer | From Page: A1

Greenwood School being restored

By Rebecca Murphy | From Page: A1 | Gallery

Cal Fire increasing staffing, hiring

By Cal Fire | From Page: B1

EID restricts watering days

By Michael Raffety | From Page: A1, 9 Comments

Lover’s Leap fall injures man

By Tahoe Tribune | From Page: A1

Tea Party meeting April 17

By Tea Party Patriots Of El Dorado Hills | From Page: A3

Town Hall Meeting on Underage Drinking May 1

By El Dorado Hills Community Vision Coalition | From Page: A6

Floating body not a body

By Cole Mayer | From Page: A7

Old mill a goner

By Dawn Hodson | From Page: A11, 2 Comments | Gallery



My turn: A fair California flat income tax

By Mark Belden | From Page: A4

DA Pierson has been outstanding

By Mountain Democrat | From Page: A4, 4 Comments



A great big thanks

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A5

Murder? Suicide?

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A5, 1 Comment

‘Drive Clean’

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A5

Middle class getting poorer?

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A5

Real estate lies

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A5, 1 Comment



Outside with Charlie: Switch gear

By Charlie Ferris | From Page: A8

Ponderosa volleyball is a family affair

By Jerry Heinzer | From Page: A8 | Gallery

Aussie team makes visit

By Special to the Democrat | From Page: A8

Griz have challenging day

By Mike Bush | From Page: A8 | Gallery

Roundup: April 15, 2014

By Democrat Staff | From Page: A9 | Gallery



At a glance: Take aim on fun

By Mimi Escabar | From Page: B2

Men to walk a mile in her shoes

By Center For Violence-Free Relationships | From Page: B2 | Gallery

Runners stampede for Sugarloaf scholarships

By El Dorado County Office of Education | From Page: B2 | Gallery

Team works to fight disease

By Placerville Kiwanis | From Page: B3

COOL School is accepting applications

By Rescue Union | From Page: B4

Band of Miwoks fund mission

By Shingle Springs Band Of Miwok Indians | From Page: B12



Crime Log: March 25-27

By Cole Mayer | From Page: A2

Weather stats 4-15-14

By Michael Raffety | From Page: A2



Ronald Russell Rohrer

By Contributor | From Page: A2

Numa Edward “Ed” Roberts

By Contributor | From Page: A2


Real Estate




By Contributor | From Page: A10


By Contributor | From Page: A10

New York Times Crossword

By Contributor | From Page: A10


By Contributor | From Page: A10

Horoscope, Thursday, April 17, 2014

By Contributor | From Page: A10

Horoscope, Wednesday, April 16, 2014

By Contributor | From Page: A10

TV Listings

By Contributor | From Page: A10


By Contributor | From Page: A10

Flying McCoys

By Contributor | From Page: A10

Speed Bump

By Contributor | From Page: A10

Working It Out

By Contributor | From Page: A10