Friday, April 18, 2014
PLACERVILLE, CALIFORNIA
99 CENTS

Victory for property rights

In a 22-page opinion a 5-4 majority of the U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling championing property rights.

Called Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District, it was another Supreme Court win for the Pacific Legal Foundation, an organization that has argued and won more cases before the Supreme Court than any one nonprofit organization.

The issue began in Florida where the late Coy Koontz sought to develop 3.7 acres of 13.9 acres of commercially zoned property near Orlando. Koontz offered to dedicate the remaining 11 acres as a conservation easement. Instead the water management district told him he could either develop 1 acre, using a retaining wall instead of sloping it down to the remainder of the land or he could paya contractor $150,000 to perform upgrades on the district’s property miles away from his land.

The Supreme Court called that extortion.

“Extortionate demands for property in the land-use context runs afoul of the Takings Clause not because they take property but because they impermissibly burden the right not to have property taken without just compensation,” the court said in its syllabus of the decision.

The Supreme Court’s decision built upon previous decisions in two cases: Nollan v. California Coastal Commission and Dolan v. City of Tigard.

“Those cases held that the government may not condition the approval of a land-use permit on the owner’s relinquishment of a portion of his property unless there is a nexus and rough proportionality between the government’s demand and the effects of the proposed land use,” the syllabus stated.

“The standard set out in Nolan and Dolan reflects the danger of governmental coercion in this context while accommodating the government’s legitimate need to offset the public costs of development through land-use exactions,” the syllabus stated.

This came to the U.S. Supreme Court because the Florida Supreme Court did its usual off-key song and dance around the Constitution. The Florida Supreme Court thought it could get around Nollan and Dolan because, according to the U.S. Supreme Court, the Florida court  ”thought it significant in this case that, unlike Nollan and Dolan, the district did not approve the petitioners application on the condition that he accede to the district’s demands; instead, the district denied the application because he refused to make concessions.”

However, the U.S. Supreme Court said, “We have said in a variety of contexts that ‘the government may not deny a benefit to a person because he exercises a constitutional right.’”

What’s more the U.S. Supreme Court added in a number of cases that “reflect an overarching principle, known as the unconstitutional conditions doctrine, that vindicates the Constitution’s enumerated rights by preventing the government from coercing people into giving them up.”

The U.S. court recognized  that “land-use permits applicants are especially vulnerable to the type of coercion that the unconstitutional conditions doctrine prohibits because the government often has broad discretion to deny a permit that is worth far more than the property it would like to take.”

“Extortionate demands of this sort frustrate the Fifth Amendment right to just compensation, and the unconstitutional conditions doctrine prohibits them.”

The court, however, recognized that the permitting process may impose costs on the public that can be offset by land dedication such as land for a wider road to accommodate increased traffic from the proposal.

The court warned, however, “The principles that undergird our decisions in Nollan and Dolan do not change depending on whether the government approves a permit on the condition that the applicant turn over his property or denies a permit because the applicant refuses to do so.”

Finally the St. Johns River Water Management District tried to claim that its demand that Koontz give it $150,000 was within its power to tax.

“But the district exaggerates both the extent to which that problem is unique to the land-use permitting context and the practical difficulty of distinguishing between the power to tax and the power to take by eminent domain. …this court had repeatedly found takings where the government, by confiscating financial obligations, achieved a result that could have been obtained through taxation.”

In other words, that was a pretty silly argument that the district could set property tax rates arbitrarily one person at a time.

This marks back-to-back victories for the Pacific Legal Foundation, which recently won a Supreme Court ruling, in Sackett v. EPA that property owners have a right to challenge federal “wetlands compliance orders” in court.

PFL Principal Attorney Paul J. Beard II argued Koontz case before the high court in January.

“The ruling is a powerful victory for everybody’s constitutional property rights, from coast to coast,” said Beard. “The Koontz family was challenging demands that were wildly excessive and had no connection to their land-use proposal. Today, the court recognized that the Koontz family was the victim of an unconstitutional taking. The court’s message was clear: Government can’t turn the land-use permitting process into an extortion machine.”

“The court has recognized that money is a form of property, and the Constitution prohibits grabbing money from property owners the same way it prohibits grabbing land without compensation,” Beard said.

The Supreme Court’s Koontz ruling is a shot across the bow of local government. Be careful about your demands.

Mountain Democrat

LEAVE A COMMENT

Discussion | 2 comments

  • FranJuly 08, 2013 - 10:18 am

    This is interesting...

    Reply | Report abusive comment
  • cookie65July 08, 2013 - 12:37 pm

    “The court has recognized that money is a form of property," Every leftist exhaling greenhouse gases considers other peoples money community property. So for them this is just another example of judicial activism. The only private property an obama voter wants protected are their entitlements.

    Reply | Report abusive comment
.

News

 
Goodbye LUPPU, hello LRPU

By Chris Daley | From Page: A1, 3 Comments

Past due state taxes bring arrest

By Cole Mayer | From Page: A1, 8 Comments

 
Sanford trial: Prosecution, defense rest

By Cole Mayer | From Page: A1 | Gallery

 
Woman, dog back from Oso

By Wendy Schultz | From Page: A1, 8 Comments | Gallery

 
 
DA candidate to remain on ballot

By Dawn Hodson | From Page: A9

Dog talk with Uncle Matty: Benji and the Bickersons

By Matthew Margolis | From Page: A10

 
CPCSD seat unfilled

By Dawn Hodson | From Page: A14, 1 Comment

Lew Uhler backs Ranalli

By News Release | From Page: A14, 6 Comments

 
.

Letters

Evacuation

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A7, 6 Comments

 
District 4 candidate

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A7, 12 Comments

Open meetings

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A7, 6 Comments

 
Volunteers and homeless camps

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A7, 26 Comments

Bicycle events and traffic control

By Letters to the Editor | From Page: A7, 5 Comments

 
.

Sports

Jennings wins national title

By Democrat Staff | From Page: A11, 1 Comment | Gallery

 
Savannah Stephens can swing the bat

By Jerry Heinzer | From Page: A11 | Gallery

King of the West roars into Placerville

By Gary Thomas | From Page: A11

 
First and goal: Bunt etiquette

By Mike Bush | From Page: A11

Oak Ridge suffers tough 2-1 setback

By Mike Bush | From Page: A11

 
Roundup: April 17, 2014

By Democrat Staff | From Page: A12 | Gallery

.

Prospecting

Plantastic sale this Saturday

By Dawn Hodson | From Page: B1 | Gallery

 
Spring art brightens government center

By Democrat Staff | From Page: B2 | Gallery

Things to do: April 18, 2014

By Democrat Calendar | From Page: B2

 
Time out: A grand time at Grand China

By Earle Camembert | From Page: B3 | Gallery

Temple Kol Shalom hosts Passover Seder

By News Release | From Page: B3

 
Student art featured for Third Saturday

By News Release | From Page: B3

Promenade in high style

By Historic Old Sacramento | From Page: B4

 
Sac State Presents ‘Gypsy’

By California State Unversity, Sacramento | From Page: B4

Friday nights are engaging at the de Young

By Fine Arts | From Page: B5

 
Hats On For the Kids raises money for children

By Democrat Staff | From Page: B6

See what is inside the vault

By Center For Sacramento History | From Page: B6

 
Eggstravaganza

By Fairytale Town | From Page: B6

Gallery tips a hat to Dr. Seuss

By Democrat Staff | From Page: B7

 
Museum presents ‘Diesel Days’

By California State Railroad Museum | From Page: B7

Engagement: Adam Frega and Wednesday Bienusa

By Democrat Staff | From Page: B8

 
Duty: Air Force Airman Brian Polk

By Democrat Staff | From Page: B8

Cal Stage presents a season of challenging productions

By California Stage | From Page: B8

 
Duty: Army Pfc. Kyle W. Beasy

By Democrat Staff | From Page: B8

KVIE calls for artists

By Kvie | From Page: B9

 
A Couple of Blaguards tell tales

By Harris Center for the Arts | From Page: B9

America’s ClayFest II celebrates a rich history

By Blue Line Arts | From Page: B14

 
Fine Arts Museums feature two shows

By Fine Arts | From Page: B15

See wildflowers on train ride

By Railtown | From Page: B15

 
Easter at Northstar is family friendly

By Northstar California | From Page: B15

.

Essentials

Crime Log: March 28-30

By Cole Mayer | From Page: A2

 
.

Obituaries

Roy Cluness Chaix

By Contributor | From Page: A2

 
Frederick Wilbur Heymann

By Contributor | From Page: A2

Arthur W. Cornell

By Contributor | From Page: A2

 
Frank “Bud” Kraus Jr.

By Contributor | From Page: A2

.

Real Estate

Faster sales with spring staging

By Ken Calhoon | From Page: HS4

 
Coldwell Banker outsells the competition

Press Release | From Page: HS7

Handsome Redmond suits modern families

Press Release | From Page: HS11

 
Growing your own

By Marni Jameson | From Page: HS14

 
Fraud workshop scheduled

Press Release | From Page: HS21

HCD launches assistance program

Press Release | From Page: HS22, 1 Comment

 
EZ Mortgages Inc. opens Placerville office

By News Release | From Page: HS22, 2 Comments

.

Comics

TV Listings

By Contributor | From Page: A13

 
Sudoku

By Contributor | From Page: A13

Speed Bump

By Contributor | From Page: A13

 
Working It Out

By Contributor | From Page: A13

Shoe

By Contributor | From Page: A13

 
Rubes

By Contributor | From Page: A13

Tundra

By Contributor | From Page: A13

 
Horoscope, Friday, April 18, 2104

By Contributor | From Page: A14

New York Times Crossword

By Contributor | From Page: A14

 
Horoscope, Sunday, April 20, 2014

By Contributor | From Page: A14

Horoscope, Saturday, April 19, 2014

By Contributor | From Page: A14

 
.

Home Source

Faster sales with spring staging

By Ken Calhoon | From Page: HS4

Coldwell Banker outsells the competition

Press Release | From Page: HS7

Handsome Redmond suits modern families

Press Release | From Page: HS11

Growing your own

By Marni Jameson | From Page: HS14

Fraud workshop scheduled

Press Release | From Page: HS21

HCD launches assistance program

Press Release | From Page: HS22, 1 Comment

EZ Mortgages Inc. opens Placerville office

By News Release | From Page: HS22, 2 Comments